Your Guide to the Best Reciprocating Saws in 2019
Finding the best reciprocating saw is at the top of the list for many people who are picking up their tools. Whether you call them a sawzall, a reciprocating saw, or “that vibrating piece of junk” they’re an essential part of many DIYer’s kit.
But how do you know which one is the best for you? There are a ton of them out there after all, and they all look about the same to the untrained eye.
If you’re in the market for a reciprocating saw then you’ve come to the right place. We’ll show you how to pick the right one for your own home, what you need to keep an eye out for, and even give you some handy tips on how to make sure you get the most out of your new saw.
In This Article:
- 1 The 10 Top-Rated Reciprocating Saws
- 2 Who Needs a Reciprocating Saw?
- 3 How We Selected Our Reciprocating Saws
- 4 The Five Best Cordless Reciprocating Saws
- 5 The Five Best Corded Reciprocating Saws
- 6 It’s all in the Blade
- 7 Keeping Safe With Your Reciprocating Saw
- 8 Reciprocating Saw FAQ
- 9 So, Get Cutting With the Best Reciprocal Saw
The 10 Top-Rated Reciprocating Saws
|Best Compact Reciprocating Saw||DEWALT DCS387B 20-volt MAX|
|Best Reciprocating Saw for Home Work||BLACK+DECKER BDCR20C 20V MAX|
|Best Value for Your Dollar||PORTER CABLE PCC670B|
|Best for Cutting Trees||WORX WX550L|
|Best for Professionals||Makita XRJ04Z|
|Best Overall Corded Reciprocating Saw||DEWALT DWE305|
|Best Reciprocating Saw for Demolition||Milwaukee 6519-31|
|Most Powerful Reciprocating Saw||Makita JR3070CT|
|Best Reciprocating Saw for Home Use||SKIL 9206-02|
|Best Budget Reciprocating Saw||WEN 3630|
Who Needs a Reciprocating Saw?
Instead, they’re most often used for rough cuts in the field and for demolition work. They’re simply not as precise as many of the other saws on the market.
They shine when you’re just tearing into drywall, wood, or even thin metal, however. If you’re looking for a saw you can wield like a low-powered lightsaber, just cutting through whatever might get in your path without particular care for precision, then you’re looking at the tool you need.
One things is for sure, however: reciprocating saws are essential pieces of kit for anyone who is planning on doing demolitions work.
With some care they can also cut through things a little bit more precisely, but the sheer power and the ergonomics of the saw make them a bad fit for those who are only looking to do some precision wood working.
How We Selected Our Reciprocating Saws
We went through quite a few of these saws trying to bring you only the best. As usual, the categories began to boil down to the same reputable brands that we usually end up recommending. Predictable, but effective in the end.
Once we had our saws down it was time to rank them and figure out which was the best for which purpose. So we had to check certain qualities of the saw, as well as make a big decision…
Corded vs. Battery Operated
Corded reciprocating saws are more powerful, and generally cheaper, than their battery operated counterparts. They can provide a pretty high amp rating, which means the saw blade will move more quickly and cut with more power.
Battery operated models, on the other hand, are great for their increased portability when compared to corded models. Not being bound to a wall socket means that you’re able to take the saw wherever you can carry it and get right to work.
Both have their uses, and we noticed a lot less difference in power than you’d think at the upper echelons of battery operated sawzalls. The truth is that lithium batteries have been a major game changer when it comes to power tools.
The choice is ultimately going to boil down to what you think is the right way to go, but we recommend the following: corded saws are best for dedicated work stations or heavy duty-work on a regular basis, cordless saws are the way to go for demolition work or situations where you need the additional portability.
Like all saws, reciprocating saws can have their power extrapolated from the amperage which they pull. More amps, more power.
That’s not the only factor, of course. The internals of the saw play a role as well, so two saws with the same amperage might have slightly different amounts of power. It’s just a matter of how efficiently things are delivered to the blade itself.
Keep in mind that sawzalls with really high amperage ratings can be an absolute bear to handle. They vibrate, shuck, slide, and generally do everything but what you want them to in the hands of someone with no experience.
Don’t shoot for super high power if all you’re planning on doing is ripping up 2×4’s in the garage or backyard. On the other hand, for demo work it’s sometimes necessary to get an extremely high-powered saw with a bimetal blade just to tear through nails, wood, and anything else which might get in your way while you’re tearing things up.
With reciprocating saws you also have some additional things to factor in: stroke length and strokes per minute (or SPM). While the amperage will give you a good idea of the overall power for the saw, the length and speed of the strokes are going to be a huge factor in determining what you’re actually looking at.
There are also orbital reciprocating saws on the market. These move in a slightly elliptical fashion rather than straight back and forwards. Studies have shown this improves cutting time and blade lifespan.
Ergonomics and Weight
Look, a reciprocating saw is never a particularly comfortable machine to run. They vibrate heavily, they slide around, and if you’re not careful they can do all manner of strange things. It’s just the nature of having a powerful saw just hanging it’s blade in the air.
That means you need to find something which fits your grip comfortably. While it may not be necessary to be precise and tearing things up, you also want to be in the right general area without overly straining your wrists, hands, and arms.
Weight is as important as the grip, particularly if you’re planning on doing a lot of demolition work. You want to be able to hold the saw for extended periods comfortably.
Trust us, the additional weight adds up quickly when you’re running a heavily vibrating saw for long periods of time.
Reciprocating saws are, by their very nature, workhorse tools. While you might be able to get away with some saws and skipping a warranty, do not do this with a reciprocating saw. Chances are that any flaws in the manufacturing are going to show up rapidly.
Just make sure you’re covered. Hopefully, you never have to deal with it, but if you do then you’re going to be thankful for the warranty.
Extra Quality of Life Features
While most models of reciprocating saw work about the same way, it’s important to note that there are a few things available which will make your life a lot easier.
A highly adjustable shoe is one of these features. The shoe is the portion of the saw which goes out along the blade. You seat the shoe in order to keep the saw tight against the material while you cut through it. We’ll talk about blade modification after the reviews, but a shoe which moves farther will keep you from having to do so.
Tool-less clamps are fantastic. They let you change out your blades without needing to use any tools. It makes things a lot more hassle-free, especially when you’re cutting through multiple types of materials on the job site.
Guide lights are also a nice touch. While they’re not necessary all of the time, they’ll certainly make things a lot easier on you when you’re cutting in low-light conditions.
There’s a wide variety of minor modifications which are made to reciprocating saws, we’ll note them as they come up in our reviews.
But, without further ado, let’s see what some real world testing tells us about our chosen models.
The Five Best Cordless Reciprocating SawsIf you’re looking for a sawzall that you can carry with you everywhere, then you’re in luck. We tested out five of the best cordless models on the market and ranked them for you. They’re all great saws at the end of the day, but each is slightly better suited for certain tasks.
Best Compact Reciprocating Saw
DEWALT DCS387B 20-volt MAX
If you’re looking for a high-end tool which can fit into small spaces, then you’ll be well served with the DeWalt DCS87B. It’s a compact reciprocating saw that makes almost no sacrifices when it comes to power.
The running theme is that DeWalt regularly tops our lists. There’s a reason for that: they make great tools and until you get into extremely high-end tools they’re usually a good bet. This one surprised even us.
Despite its diminutive frame, the saw has an impressive stroke of 1 ⅛” and a variable speed trigger that runs from 0-2,900 SPM. It’s a lot of power and it’s all fed by DeWalt’s 20V battery which means it’s compatible with a wide range of tools.
The only real drawback here is the high price. Lithium batteries are expensive anyways and DeWalt’s tools are also rather expensive in the end. It also vibrates heavily due to the smaller, lightweight frame.
Best Reciprocating Saw for Home Work
BLACK+DECKER BDCR20C 20V MAX
While it may not have the power or durability of many of the tools on our list, we recommend the BDCR20C for those who are using their saw for light duty around the home. The whole kit comes in, as of the time of this writing, at a bit under a hundred dollars which lets it fit into most budgets.
The motor on this saw reaches up to 3000spm, it is also lightweight and easy to maneuver although it vibrated more heavily than any of the other saws which we tested. It also suffers from a relatively short battery life during testing the sessions lasted between twenty-five and forty-five minutes depending on how heavily it was being used.
It’s not going to win any awards for power but it’ll do the job at the end of the day. It also has an electric brake, stopping the saw as soon as you let off the trigger. Most cordless saws have this ability but it’s a nice feature to see in one this cheap.
It also has a relatively short stroke length of ⅞”. While it’ll make short work of a 2×4 and nails, this might not be the go-to saw for heavy demolition work.
Best Value for Your Dollar
PORTER CABLE PCC670B
While cheaper than most of those on our list, we quickly found the PCC670B to be a great place to put your money. For non-professional use it’s probably our favorite, coming in ahead of the Black and Decker model above when it comes to power and smoothness.
If you’re looking for the best matching of price and function then you’re in the right place. This tool performs much better than the price point would indicate and has some extra features that make it stand out.
Our favorite bit? The non-marking shoe. While reciprocating saws are rarely used for precision work, you don’t always want to leave a mark on whatever you’re cutting.
The main problem is that it feels “cheap” although we didn’t have any problems with it during testing. Comparing it to a DeWalt or Milwaukee tool you’ll be able to tell an immediate difference in how well they’re put together.
Best for Cutting Trees
The profile of the WX550L looks a bit odd for those who are used to a standard configuration in their reciprocating saws. On the other hand, it does lend itself well to tree trimming while still being able to take the wide variety of blades which are made for sawzalls.
WORX tends to modify tools a little bit from what most people are used to. In this case, the trigger is in line with the blade and it has a wide handguard and it can be converted into a large jigsaw by rotating the blade.
The hand guard and orientation make this one ideal for trimming trees, but the short battery life and awkward orientation of the trigger compared to a normal sawzall make it a bit harder to use for normal sawing tasks.
That said, it’s a versatile tool and if you’re short on space you may want to give it some consideration.
Best for Professionals
While a bit smaller than some of the really high-end models out there it’s not a full compact. It produces a pretty incredible amount of power and runs smoothly for extended durations. Add in a high build-quality and you’re looking at something special.
It delivers up to 2,800 SPM with a variable speed trigger and has the longest stroke of the cordless models we tested at 1 ¼”. All of this leads to a great cutting experience overall, it was undoubtedly the smoothest and most powerful of the cordless models we tried out.
It even has a tool-less blade change mechanism. Unfortunately it doesn’t come with a case and Makita batteries are quite expensive.
The Five Best Corded Reciprocating SawsSometimes even the very best cordless models won’t cut it. When it’s time to break out the big guns you’re going to need a plug-in sawzall. There are a lot of them on the market and we tested the five models below and found all of them to be a great option.
Best Overall Corded Reciprocating Saw
For those who can afford it, the DWE305 is one of the most powerful and reliable sawzalls on the market. Coming in with an incredible amount of power, a long cord, and DeWalt quality it’s simply the best you’re going to do for the most part.
It runs up to 2900SPM with a 1 ⅛” stroke. The 12 amp motor drives the blade through metal and wood easily as long as the right blade is selected.
It has all of the quality of life features which differentiate a good saw from a great one as well. Tool-less blade changes, an adjustable shoe, and the blade can be positioned along both vertical and horizontal planes.
It comes bare tool, however, and it lacks some of the really advanced features like an oscillating blade.
Best Reciprocating Saw for Demolition
Milwaukee is famous for their tools and their sawzalls are no exception. This saw is powerful, robust, and enormous which makes it great for demolition jobs. It does lack some of the precision of the DeWalt above however.
It’s an expensive machine but there’s a lot to recommend here. It comes in with a 12 amp motor which pushes 3000 SPM and a 1 ⅛” stroke. You’ll be able to cut through damn near anything with this one.
On top of that it has an internal counterweight which helps to reduce the vibration. That makes it easier to run for long hours while retaining feeling in your hands.
Most Powerful Reciprocating Saw
While the majority of the corded models we tested ranged from 7.5 to 12 amp, this beast of a saw from Makita comes in with a solid 15 amps. Add in the 2800 SPM and a 1 ¼” stroke and there’s some serious potential here.
This saw isn’t quite as well built as the two corded models above but it’s a solid piece of work. The main draw is still the power, although the grip is excellent as well. During testing we were able to make short work of everything the saw came across without being uncomfortable.
Like the Milwaukee above it has an anti-vibration quality built right in. We don’t think it was quite up to par with the Milwaukee but it could have just been the extra amperage going through the saw as well.
Unfortunately, the shoe and blade holder don’t seem to have been built up to snuff for the motor. There’s a bit of wiggle with the blade and the shoe doesn’t feel as solid as most of those we tried.
Best Reciprocating Saw for Home Use
If you’re just building up your tool collection, then you might want to take a look at this saw from SKIL. It’s not quite the budget option but it’s relatively cheap and provides a good amount of power and convenience for the price.
It was the weakest of the corded models we tested, with a motor which is only rated for 7.5 amps and is a bit slower to cut than the others. It’s solid, however, and you won’t have to worry about the battery running out.
That’s not the case here, if you’re willing to forgo extras then the 9306-02 will serve you well for a long time to come.
Best Budget Reciprocating Saw
If you’re not planning on needing a workhorse in the future then you’ll find a quick investment in the WEN 3630 will get you through basic tasks for a low cost of entry. It’s not the most solid saw around, it feels pretty cheap in all honesty, but it gets the job done which is the important part.
It does have a heavily repositionable head. Unlike many models, which only allow turns of 90 degrees at a time you’ll find it has eight settings, allowing you to set the blade at 45 degrees through the whole circle.
Where it shines is for those who only rarely use their saw. If you plan on trimming a couple trees and maybe the occasional 2×4 or 4×4 you’ll be well served with its little 10 amp motor. Professionals will want to shy away, however.
It’s all in the Blade
Perhaps just as important as your reciprocating saw is the blade which goes into it.
Fortunately, you don’t need to be an engineer in order to understand which blade to pick: they’re usually labeled for the material they’re meant for.
What we do recommend is not going cheap with your blades, even if you’re using a cheaper reciprocating saw. A cheap saw really isn’t going to affect the lifespan of the blade in question.
There are also specialty blades available, including those meant for masonry. If it exists there’s a blade that you can chuck in a reciprocating saw for it.
Wood blades are usually fine in material with nails, but if the material is heavily infested with nails then you may want to go with a carbide grit blade instead. These will allow you to go through pretty much anything quickly, but be careful not to overheat them as it can destroy the grit.
Keeping Safe With Your Reciprocating Saw
Reciprocating saws are powerful tools, but that same power means that you need to be cautious when you’re using them.
The first is to see whether or not your tool has an electric brake. You can tell by spooling up the motor and letting off the trigger. If the blade stops, you have a brake and you can safely stop the saw while it’s still within a material.
If you don’t have a break it’s important to slowly let off the trigger and pull the blade up. Since the blade will run for a few more strokes once you’ve stopped apply power it runs the risk of snagging and kicking back. This can knock you on your butt on the ground but it can also do things like knock you off a ladder or ledge.
You’ll also want to make sure you have the right blade. While blades can sometimes be used on different materials it will cut the life of the blade and it runs the risk of breaking while in operation. That’ll send shrapnel around, which is a hairy situation for anyone to be in.
Lastly, avoid overheating the blade if possible. You’ll naturally get some heat in between cuts, especially in metal, but you can warp the blade if you repeatedly heat it and keep using it. That will lead to a break in the future at the very least.
Reciprocating Saw FAQ
You’ve got questions, we’ve got answers. In the following section we’ll break down some of the most common questions about these handy tools.
Q: Can I use a reciprocating saw to cut…
A: We’ll stop you there. If it exists, there’s probably a reciprocating blade which is designed to take care of it. Ferrous metals, non-ferrous metals, masonry, wood, plastic. Outside of some truly exotic materials like titanium it will all depend on the blade you use.
Q: Is a sawzall the same thing as a reciprocating saw?
A: Yes. The Sawzall was the original Milwaukee model in the past but has become a catchall name for the saws. Think of it like how Xerox has become synonymous with photocopying.
Q: What about a hackzall?
A: The original Milwaukee Hackzall was a compact reciprocating saw, the term is used interchangeably in some areas but strictly speaking it’s a catch-all for compact reciprocating saws.
Q: What kind of blades do I need for demolition?
A: At the very least a good bimetal or carbide grit blade is essential for taking apart most things. Metal or masonry blades may also be necessary depending on the construction which is being taken apart.
Q: Can I use a reciprocating saw for precision work?
A: Honestly, if you’re asking then you probably need to do some more work with one. They’re not extremely precise tools but user skill can make up for quite a bit. For intricate cuts in a similar fashion you’d be much better off with a jigsaw.
Q: My blade is too long to cut something without banging into what’s behind it, can I do anything?
A: An adjustable shoe will let you neck up on the blade. If you lack one or the final setting on your shoe isn’t far enough out to prevent it you can also clip a blade to fit. Make sure to do it quickly and with something which has enough force to prevent warping the blade.
Q: My saw keeps slipping, what can I do?
A: Practice with your saw a bit. You need to set the shoe firmly. Some models will wiggle regardless, but if you use the shoe properly and angle the blade into the piece the slot it cuts will hold it straight.
So, Get Cutting With the Best Reciprocal Saw
While they’re not the first thing which comes to mind for most people when it comes to saws, a reciprocal saw can make a huge difference. If you find yourself taking things apart regularly in your workshop or doing demolition for work then they’ll pay dividends.
So, what are you waiting for? We’re confident one of our reviewed models are right for you. Pick it up now and get to hacking.